Revision notes โ€บ Tumours

Approach to a suspected bone tumour (and biopsy principles)

A bone lesion may be an incidental benign finding, a metastasis, myeloma or a primary sarcoma. A systematic approach (history, radiograph analysis, staging, then biopsy at the right place by the right team) prevents the classic disasters of inappropriate fixation and contaminated biopsy tracts.

Key points

  • Age, site and aggressiveness drive the differential diagnosis.
  • Over 40, a destructive lesion is usually metastasis or myeloma, but a solitary lesion needs proof.
  • Stage before biopsy: MRI of the whole bone, CT chest, bone scan or PET-CT, bloods and myeloma screen.
  • Biopsy at or with the definitive treating centre, in line with the resection incision.
  • Send biopsy tissue for both histology and microbiology.
  • Never nail a pathological fracture through an undiagnosed solitary lesion.
  • Enneking staging links tumour biology to the surgical margin needed.

The basics

Every orthopaedic surgeon will meet unexpected bone lesions. The key questions are:

  • Is it aggressive or non-aggressive?
  • How old is the patient?
  • Is it solitary or multiple?

Age is the most powerful clue. In children and young adults the concern is primary sarcoma (osteosarcoma, Ewing's). Over about 40, a destructive lesion is most often a metastasis or myeloma, but a solitary lesion must never be assumed to be a metastasis until proven.

Many benign lesions (non-ossifying fibroma, enchondroma, simple bone cyst, fibrous dysplasia) can be diagnosed confidently from radiographs and left alone.

Primary bone sarcomas are rare, and in the UK they are managed by a small number of specialist bone sarcoma centres.

Assessment

History:

  • Pain, especially non-mechanical, constant, or night pain; pain is a warning sign in a cartilage lesion
  • Swelling or a mass, its duration and growth
  • Systemic symptoms: weight loss, fever, sweats
  • Previous cancer (breast, prostate, lung, kidney, thyroid), smoking
  • Pathological fracture after trivial trauma
  • Previous radiotherapy, Paget's disease or a known syndrome

Examination:

  • The lesion itself: size, depth, tenderness, warmth, fixity
  • Regional lymph nodes and neurovascular status
  • Breasts, thyroid, abdomen, and prostate in men where appropriate
  • Other bones, the spine and neurology

Never miss

  • Night pain or rest pain with a bone lesion.
  • Aggressive features: wide zone of transition, cortical destruction, soft tissue mass, aggressive periosteal reaction.
  • Pathological fracture through an undiagnosed lesion.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a solitary lytic lesion in an older adult is a metastasis and nailing it.
  • Performing a biopsy before MRI or away from the specialist centre.
  • Using a transverse incision or crossing compartments for biopsy.
  • Forgetting to culture the biopsy.

Read the full note (6 more sections) and test yourself

Free for everyone, no card: exam-style questions on approach to a suspected bone tumour (and biopsy principles) with every option explained, real X-rays, and a Consultant on Call to explain anything you get wrong.

Create a free account โ†’ Log in

Further reading: ["Mankin HJ, Lange TA, Spanier SS. The hazards of biopsy in patients with malignant primary bone and soft-tissue tumors. J Bone Joint Surg Am, 1982.","Enneking WF, Spanier SS, Goodman MA. A system for the surgical staging of musculoskeletal sarcoma. Clin Orthop Relat Res, 1980.","NICE guideline NG12: Suspected cancer: recognition and referral.","NICE Improving Outcomes Guidance: Improving outcomes for people with sarcoma (2006)."]

โ† All revision notes ยท Question of the day ยท X-ray of the day