Revision notes โบ Hip arthroplasty
Bearing surfaces and metal-on-metal hips
The articulating surfaces of a hip replacement determine its wear, the type of debris produced and the long-term risk of osteolysis and failure. Metal-on-metal hips are a key example of how a promising bearing caused widespread harm, leading to national surveillance in the UK.
Key points
- Bearing choice determines wear rate, debris type and long-term osteolysis.
- Highly cross-linked polyethylene has greatly reduced wear and osteolysis.
- Ceramic bearings have very low wear but can fracture or squeak.
- MoM failure was driven by metal debris causing adverse reactions and pseudotumours.
- Small components, women and steep cups had higher MoM failure rates.
- Investigate with blood cobalt and chromium, MARS MRI or ultrasound, and radiographs.
- The NJR and MHRA alerts were central to identifying and managing failing MoM implants.
The basics
A bearing couple is the combination of femoral head and acetabular surface. The common options are:
- Metal-on-polyethylene (MoP): cobalt-chrome head on polyethylene. Cheap, forgiving and widely used.
- Ceramic-on-polyethylene (CoP): ceramic head on polyethylene, with lower wear than metal heads.
- Ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC): very low wear and inert debris, used particularly in younger patients.
- Metal-on-metal (MoM): cobalt-chrome on cobalt-chrome, either as hip resurfacing or as large-diameter heads on stems. Now rarely used.
The aim of each is to minimise wear and the biological response to wear particles, which is the main driver of osteolysis and aseptic loosening.
Tribology and wear
Tribology is the science of friction, lubrication and wear. Key ideas:
- Lubrication: the lambda ratio compares fluid film thickness with surface roughness. Fluid film lubrication (high lambda) separates surfaces and minimises wear; this is favoured by smooth, hard surfaces, larger heads and low clearance.
- Wear mechanisms include adhesion, abrasion, fatigue and third-body wear (cement or bone particles trapped in the joint).
- Wear modes describe the situation: mode 1 is the intended articulation, mode 2 a primary surface against a secondary surface (for example head on bare shell after liner wear-through), mode 3 third-body wear, mode 4 two secondary surfaces rubbing (for example neck on cup rim, or taper corrosion).
Polyethylene particles of around submicron size are taken up by macrophages, producing cytokines that activate osteoclasts and cause osteolysis. Highly cross-linked polyethylene, produced by irradiation and then heat treatment to deal with free radicals, has dramatically reduced wear and osteolysis.
Never miss
- Rising metal ion levels or a pseudotumour on imaging in a MoM hip.
- Systemic symptoms in a MoM patient (cardiomyopathy, neuropathy, visual or hearing change): consider cobalt toxicity.
Common pitfalls
- Revising a fractured ceramic to a metal head (residual ceramic particles destroy it).
- Assuming normal radiographs exclude adverse reaction to metal debris.
- Forgetting trunnionosis in non-MoM large-head metal-on-polyethylene hips.
- Delaying revision until there is extensive soft tissue destruction.
Read the full note (5 more sections) and test yourself
Free for everyone, no card: exam-style questions on bearing surfaces and metal-on-metal hips with every option explained, real X-rays, and a Consultant on Call to explain anything you get wrong.
Create a free account โ Log inFurther reading: ["MHRA. Medical Device Alerts on all metal-on-metal hip replacements (2010, 2012 and 2017 updates).","National Joint Registry Annual Report (current edition): metal-on-metal bearings.","Pandit H, et al. Pseudotumours associated with metal-on-metal hip resurfacings. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2008."]
โ All revision notes ยท Question of the day ยท X-ray of the day