Revision notes โ€บ Lower limb trauma

Extracapsular (intertrochanteric and subtrochanteric) hip fractures

Extracapsular hip fractures run through the trochanteric region or just below it, outside the joint capsule, so the femoral head blood supply is preserved and fixation is the rule. The main decisions are implant choice and getting a stable reduction, guided by fracture stability and NICE.

Key points

  • Extracapsular fractures keep the femoral head blood supply, so fixation is standard.
  • NICE: sliding hip screw for fractures above and including the lesser trochanter; nail for subtrochanteric fractures.
  • Reverse oblique and lateral wall-deficient patterns are better treated with a nail.
  • Tip-apex distance under 25 mm reduces cut-out risk.
  • Reduction quality matters more than implant choice.
  • Subtrochanteric proximal fragment goes into flexion, abduction and external rotation.
  • Prodromal thigh pain on bisphosphonates suggests an atypical femoral fracture: image the other side.
  • Image the whole femur before fixing a subtrochanteric or pathological fracture.

The basics

Extracapsular fractures make up roughly half of hip fractures. They include:

  • Intertrochanteric (pertrochanteric) fractures, between the greater and lesser trochanters.
  • Subtrochanteric fractures, in the zone from the lesser trochanter to about 5 cm below it.

Because the fracture is outside the capsule, the femoral head keeps its blood supply, so avascular necrosis is rare and the fracture can be fixed rather than replaced. Bone is well vascularised cancellous bone, so union is usual.

The patients are often older and frailer than those with intracapsular fractures, and blood loss is greater because bleeding is not contained by the capsule. All the general hip fracture principles apply: early analgesia with a nerve block, orthogeriatric care, surgery the day of or day after admission, and full weight bearing afterwards.

Anatomy and mechanism

The trochanteric region has strong muscle attachments that drive displacement:

  • Gluteus medius and minimus on the greater trochanter: abduct the proximal fragment.
  • Iliopsoas on the lesser trochanter: flexes and externally rotates the proximal fragment.
  • Short external rotators: external rotation.
  • Adductors: pull the shaft into adduction and shortening.

In subtrochanteric fractures this gives the classic deformity: proximal fragment flexed, abducted and externally rotated, shaft adducted and short. This is why reduction can be difficult.

The posteromedial cortex (calcar region, around the lesser trochanter) carries compressive load. If it is comminuted, the fracture collapses into varus. The lateral wall of the greater trochanter acts as a buttress for a sliding screw; if it is broken or thin, the head and neck fragment slides too far and the shaft medialises.

Mechanism is usually a low-energy fall in the elderly. In younger patients and subtrochanteric fractures, consider high energy or pathological causes.

Never miss

  • Atypical femoral fracture with an impending fracture on the other side.
  • Pathological fracture from an unknown primary: do not nail without considering biopsy and staging.

Common pitfalls

  • Using a sliding hip screw for a reverse oblique fracture, leading to shaft medialisation and failure.
  • Accepting a varus reduction in a subtrochanteric fracture.
  • Placing the head screw high and anterior with a large tip-apex distance.
  • Missing a metastatic lesion or atypical fracture by not imaging the full femur.
  • Forgetting larger blood loss and the need for transfusion monitoring.

Read the full note (7 more sections) and test yourself

Free for everyone, no card: exam-style questions on extracapsular (intertrochanteric and subtrochanteric) hip fractures with every option explained, real X-rays, and a Consultant on Call to explain anything you get wrong.

Create a free account โ†’ Log in

Further reading: ["NICE CG124: Hip fracture: management (2011, updated 2023).","Baumgaertner MR et al. The value of the tip-apex distance in predicting failure of fixation of peritrochanteric fractures of the hip. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1995.","Shane E et al. Atypical subtrochanteric and diaphyseal femoral fractures: second report of an ASBMR task force. J Bone Miner Res 2014.","Meinberg EG et al. Fracture and dislocation classification compendium. J Orthop Trauma 2018."]

โ† All revision notes ยท Question of the day ยท X-ray of the day