Revision notes โ€บ Basic science

Fracture healing, delayed union and nonunion

Fracture healing is a regenerative process that depends on biology and mechanics working together. Understanding how bone heals, and why it sometimes fails, lets you choose the right fixation and diagnose and treat nonunion logically.

Key points

  • Secondary healing: haematoma, soft callus, hard callus, remodelling.
  • Absolute stability gives primary healing; relative stability gives callus.
  • Perren: under about 2% strain lamellar bone, 2 to 10% callus, over 10% granulation tissue.
  • Hypertrophic nonunion needs stability; atrophic nonunion needs biology and stability.
  • Always exclude infection in a nonunion.
  • Autograft is osteogenic, osteoinductive and osteoconductive.
  • The diamond concept: cells, scaffold, growth factors, stability, plus vascularity.

The basics

Bone is unusual in that it heals by regenerating the original tissue rather than forming a scar.

Healing needs two things:

  • Biology: a blood supply, living cells and signalling molecules
  • Mechanics: the right amount of stability for the type of healing intended

Delayed union means a fracture has not healed in the time normally expected for that injury and site, but still has the potential to heal.

Nonunion means healing has stopped and will not occur without intervention. A commonly quoted research definition is a fracture at least nine months old with no visible progress in healing over three consecutive months, but in practice surgeons diagnose nonunion earlier when healing has clearly stalled.

Nonunion causes pain, loss of function, deformity, implant failure and considerable cost.

Biology of fracture healing

Secondary (indirect) healing, the commonest type, occurs with relative stability (casts, nails, bridging plates, external fixators):

  • Haematoma and inflammation: platelets and inflammatory cells release cytokines and growth factors (such as PDGF, TGF-beta, BMPs and VEGF)
  • Soft callus: mesenchymal cells differentiate into chondrocytes and fibroblasts, forming cartilage and fibrous tissue that bridge the gap
  • Hard callus: endochondral ossification converts cartilage into woven bone
  • Remodelling: woven bone is replaced by lamellar bone over months to years, guided by loading (Wolff's law)

Primary (direct) healing occurs with absolute stability and anatomical compression (lag screws and compression plates). Cutting cones of osteoclasts followed by osteoblasts cross the fracture line directly, without visible callus.

Hypoxia drives cartilage formation; good vascularity favours direct bone formation.

Never miss

  • Infected nonunion presenting as persistent pain with raised inflammatory markers or a sinus.

Common pitfalls

  • Fixing a simple fracture with a gap and a flexible construct, creating high strain.
  • Adding bone graft to a hypertrophic nonunion that only needs stability.
  • Not sampling for infection when revising a nonunion.
  • Ignoring smoking, diabetes and vitamin D deficiency.

Read the full note (6 more sections) and test yourself

Free for everyone, no card: exam-style questions on fracture healing, delayed union and nonunion with every option explained, real X-rays, and a Consultant on Call to explain anything you get wrong.

Create a free account โ†’ Log in

Further reading: ["Perren SM. Physical and biological aspects of fracture healing with special reference to internal fixation. Clin Orthop Relat Res, 1979.","Giannoudis PV, Einhorn TA, Marsh D. Fracture healing: the diamond concept. Injury, 2007.","Weber BG, Cech O. Pseudarthrosis. Hans Huber, 1976."]

โ† All revision notes ยท Question of the day ยท X-ray of the day